Don't fuck up. I'm watching you. If you care about my input though, I'd rather you keep the karaoke out. Just a suggestion :P
I dont know about the resolution. Are the DVDs really 640x480? I would keep the resolution 1:1 and Matroska supports this neat anamorphic feature too, if its required.
Different colors for each character sound good, but different fonts? I dont know.
Im no encoding freak but I'm a fan of the idea, if you already have the DVDs, do the best possible Rip. With coreavc and the newer ffdshow builds even h.264 HD material can be played on weaker machines so I expect the best possible encode ;)
And I dont really care about Karoke as long as it's not annoying.
Good luck with the new project. Im anticipating it :)
Fonts? What fonts? VLC doesn't do fonts.
JJS, what I wanted to tell you on IRC was that I have a few fonts that are tech/computerish. I can send you some HTML previews of the packages, or I can send you the entire collections. They aren't big, under 2MB each. Contact me on IRC.
In case it might help out, the fonts that the Intelligent devices talk in are Lucida Console, in the fansubbing of Triad's Nanoha and Nanoha A's.
At least, I'm pretty sure that it is.
I've seen 720x480 (h.264) fansubbed animes and watched them on my monitor (1280x1024). There isn't a problem seeing them in their original resolution on a monitor whose aspect ratio is 4:3. It's like watching widescreen DVDs with black bars at the top and bottom of the screen. However, the only people benefitting from widescreen fansubbed animes are those with widescreen monitors though.
I wish I had a widescreen monitor. T_T
But either way will work.